Aerial view of a Southwest Michigan inland lake, photographed over Lake Doster in Plainwell
Lake Market Data

Eagle Lake

Homes along Eagle Lake in Kalamazoo and Mattawan.

Median sold price
$800,000

Up 45% since 2016

Median of 7 closed sales on Eagle Lake, Nov 2025 – Nov 2026.

Get these when they change →

Aerial by Jason O'Brien · 18th Hour Productions

Eagle Lake market stats

Homes for sale
3
Median list price
$699,500
Homes sold
7
Trailing 12 months
Months of supply
5.1
Median days on market
111
Homes for sale now

The lake

About Eagle Lake

Eagle Lake sits west of Kalamazoo near Mattawan, around 224 acres, and it is shallow — reported at about 10 feet at its deepest. Homes on it carry either a Kalamazoo or a Mattawan address depending on which side of the line they fall, which can make it look like two different lakes when you are searching. It is one.

Shallow water is not a flaw, but it is a fact worth having before you buy: it warms earlier, it grows more weed through the summer, and it sets limits on what kind of boat makes sense. If you have been comparing this lake against a deep one at a similar price, those are not the same purchase.

Being this close to Kalamazoo and right by the I-94 corridor, it is one of the easier lakes here to live on year-round rather than seasonally.

What's on the market, and what sold.

Median sold price over time
Eagle Lake, 2016 to 2026

$570,000 to $825,000, a change of 45% across 43 quarterly readings.

$464k$676k$888k201620182020202220242026

Each point is the median of closed sales in the twelve months ending that quarter.

Recent sales

Every sale behind the number

Closed home sales on Eagle Lake over the last three years, with the frontage each one reported and the resulting price per foot. Vacant land is excluded. Only sales in the trailing twelve months feed the published median; the rest are listed so the full sales history can be checked.

ClosedAddressClose priceFrontage$ / front ftIn index
Oct 9, 2026727 Treasure Island, Mattawan,$600,00041 ft$14,634yes
Sep 14, 20266825 3rd, Kalamazoo,$1,695,00082 ft$20,671yes
Jun 2, 2026459 Treasure Island, Mattawan,$1,500,000165 ft$9,091yes
May 29, 20267025 Eagle Hts, Mattawan,$850,00090 ft$9,444yes
May 1, 2026931 Treasure Island, Mattawan,$800,00081 ft$9,877yes
Apr 9, 2026963 Treasure Island, Mattawan,$410,00097 ft$4,227yes
Jan 30, 20261009 Treasure Island, Mattawan,$725,00040 ft$18,125yes
Oct 14, 20251466 Eagle Lake, Kalamazoo,$655,90060 ft$10,932older
Oct 6, 2025816 Eagle Lake, Kalamazoo,$850,00066 ft$12,879older
Aug 29, 2025940 Eagle Lake, Kalamazoo,$875,00060 ft$14,583older
Jul 10, 20251128 Eagle Lake, Kalamazoo,$820,000104 ft$7,885older
Jun 18, 20258281 Heritage, Kalamazoo,$325,000Shared—no frontage
Feb 21, 20251230 Eagle Lake, Kalamazoo,$1,465,00066 ft$22,197older
Jan 24, 20251400 Eagle Lake, Kalamazoo,$1,002,600100 ft$10,026older
Dec 13, 2024759 Treasure Island, Mattawan,$305,00080 ft$3,813older
Jul 24, 2024816 Eagle Lake, Kalamazoo,$769,00066 ft$11,652older
Jun 21, 2024689 Treasure Island, Mattawan,$1,285,456120 ft$10,712older
Mar 29, 2024618 Aquaview, Kalamazoo,$920,00082 ft$11,220older
Mar 18, 2024582 Aquaview, Kalamazoo,$849,00088 ft$9,648older
Jan 26, 2024530 Treasure Island, Mattawan,$960,00099 ft$9,697older

Sales marked no frontage are real sales of real homes, but the water is not privately theirs to measure — a condominium or a home in a lakeside community whose frontage belongs to the association, or a record carrying a placeholder figure rather than a survey. They count toward the sale prices on this page and are deliberately not divided into a price per foot, because that number would describe shoreline the seller shared with their neighbours.

Sales marked older closed before the current twelve-month index window. Sales marked outlier fall inside it but sit outside the statistical fence — a short frontage under an expensive house produces a very high figure per foot, and that number describes the house rather than the shoreline. Both are listed rather than hidden so the median can be checked against the full record.

Sale data from the MLS, deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Sold alerts

Know what sells on Eagle Lake.

Every time a home closes on Eagle Lake, I'll email you the address, what it asked, what it actually sold for, and how long it sat. That is the whole email.

No newsletter, no drip sequence, no “just checking in.” If you ever want out, every email has a one-click unsubscribe.

7 homes sold on Eagle Lake in the last twelve months, so that is roughly the number of emails to expect.

How this figure is calculated

The price-per-front-foot figure is the median closed sale price divided by feet of water frontage, for homes that sold on Eagle Lake in the trailing twelve months.

Listings with reported frontage outside 20 to 1,500 feet are excluded as data-entry error, and statistical outliers are trimmed before the median is calculated. We publish this figure only where there are at least eight qualifying sales in the window — below that, the sample is too small to be reliable.

Homes whose water access is shared, association-held or deeded are excluded from the price-per-foot figure as well, though their sale prices still count toward the median sale price. A condominium or a home in a lakeside community may report the frontage of the whole development, and dividing one home’s price by shoreline it shares with its neighbours produces a number that means nothing. Sales like these are shown in the table below and marked, rather than removed from the record.

Data comes from the MLS and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Jason O'Brien's track record

  • 5.0from 35 Google reviews
  • 71closed transactions
  • $16.9Min volume since 2018

IDXListing information provided by the MichRIC Broker Reciprocity program.

Last updated: 11/9/26

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Any use of the search facilities of data on the site, other than by a consumer looking to purchase real estate, is prohibited.

PREMIERE Group at Real Broker, LLC does not display the entire MichRIC Broker Reciprocity database on this web site. Listings of brokerages other than PREMIERE Group at Real Broker, LLC include the name of the listing brokerage and listing agent.

Copyright 2026 MichRIC, LLC. All rights reserved.